List of cases filed on grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy

List of cases filed on grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy

GRANT OF MACP ON PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY:

LIST OF CASES FILED

The list of cases filed on the subject is given below for your reference.

SL	O.A.No., CWP.No. SLP Civil (CC) No	Parties	Date of Order	Name of court	Remarks
RAJPAL Vs UoI & Others
1	OA No.1038/CH/2010 (Advocate : Mr. V.K.Verma)	Raj Pal s/o Tilak Ram, CAT, Chandigarh	31.5.2011	CAT, Chandigarh.	OA is allowed for grant of MACP in the hierarchy of Promotional post.
2	CWP No.19387 of (O&M)(Advocate : D.K.Bhisnoi)	Union of India represented by DoP&T and others Vs. Raj Pal and another.	19.10.2011	High Court of Punjab and Haryana at  Chandigarh	Order dated 31-5-2011 of Hon’ble CAT, Chandigarh is upheld. CWP filed by Respondents dismissed.
3	SLP No.cc-7467 of 2013 against order dated 19-10-2011 of the Hon’ble High Court	Union of India represented by DoP&T and others Vs. Raj Pal and another.	15.4.2013	Supreme Court of India	SLP filed by the Union of India is dismissed
SANJAY KUMAR & Ors Vs UoI & Ors
4	OA No.904/2012 (Mr. M.K.Bhardwaj)	Sanjay Kumar, UDC and 18 others Vs. UOI nted byMinistry of Defense and others.	26.11.2012	CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi.	OA is allowed for grant of MACP in next promotional post i.e. Assistant in PB-2+Grade PayRs.4200.
5	W.P.(C) 4552/2013 [PENDING] (Mr. M.K. Bhardwaj)	UNION OF INDIA Vs. SANJAY KUMAR & ORS.		Delhi High Court	Hearing Date Court No. 5 Next Date: 04/09/2014
M V Mahanan Nair Vs UoI & Ors
6	OA No.816/12	M.V.Mohanan Nair, S/o M.R.Vishwanathan Nair, Photocopier CAT, Ernakulam Bench & others Vs Union of India	29.1.2013	CAT, PrincipalBench Ernakulam Bench	OA is allowed for consideration of MACP in the hierarchy of promotional post.
7	OP(CAT). NO.2000 OF 2013 (Z)	UOI &  ORS. .Vs. M.V.  MOHANAN NAIR	24.06.2013	High court of Kerala at Ernakulam	In the result, this original petition is dismissed in limine
8	Special Leave Petition (Civil) 21803 OF 2014	UOI & ORS. .Vs. M.V. MOHANAN NAIR		Supreme Court of India	PENDING
9	OA No.1798 of 2014 Advocate : Shri Yogesh Sharma	Mahendra Kumar Dubey, S/o Sh. R.D. Dubey, Working as Programme Executive, In Doordarsan Kendra, Delhi VS UOI through the Secretary, Ministry of lnformation & Broadcastin	22.05.2014	Cat Delhi	OA is allowed for consideration of MACP in the hierarchy of promotional post within a period of one month
KISHAN SWARUP SHARMA Vs SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE
10	OA No.2548/2014 MA No.2167/2014 (Advocate : Shri M.K.Bhardwaj	Kishan Swarup Sharma, working as PPO(E), Meerut & 28 others V/S Secretary, Ministry of Agriculture,	31.07.2014	CAT, New Delhi	OA is allowed For consider the case of the applicants in the light of the aforesaid orders
PRADEEP KUMAR Vs SECRETARY MIN. OF INFORMATION & BROADCASTING
11	OA No.988 of 2014 MA No.872 of 2014 (Advocate : Shri M.K. Bhardwaj	Pradeep Kumar. AE (C) Rohini, Delhi & 20 others VS Secretary, Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, Shastri Bhawan. New Delhi	22.03.2014	CAT. New Delhi	in view of the above position. we dispose of this OA at the admission stage itself with the direction to the respondents to consider the representations of the applicants in the light of the judgment of Punjab and Haryana High Court in CWP No.19387/2011 (supra) as upheld by the Apex Court in SLP (CC) No.7467/2013(supra) and decide their cases under intimation to them. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs.
12	O.A. No. 1834/2014 Advocate: Shri Yogesh Sharma.	Mohd Hamid  Hussain, Working as APRO (Defence), Sr.Grade Group B Officer In the office of: DPR, Ministry of Defence New Delhi- & 34 others VS UOI through the Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,	23.05.2014	Central Administrative Tribunal PrincipalBench New Delhi	In view of the aforesaid submission made by the applicants and the documents available on record. we dispose of this OA at the admission stage itself with a direction to the respondents to consider the case of the applicants in terms of the aforesaid orders within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. if the applicants are similarly placed, they shall also be treated alike
OM PRAKASH Vs SECRETARY, NCERT
13	OA 864/2014 Advocate: Shri M.K. Bhardwaj)	Shri Om Prakash NCERT, New Delhi  VS Secretary (NCERT)  New Delhi	12.3.2014	Central Administrative Tribunal PrincipalBench, New Delhi	In view of the above position. we dispose of this OA at the admission stage itself with the direction to the respondents to consider the representations of the applicants in the light of the judgment of Punjab and Haryana High Court in CWP No.19387/2011 (supra) as upheld by the Apex Court in SLP (CC) No.7467/2013(supra) and decide their cases under intimation to them. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a cop of this order.
14	W.P.(C) 3608/2014	NCERT,New Delhi VS Shri Om Prakash & others	14.07.2014	High court of Delhi  at New Delhi	CWP filed by Respondents dismissed.
BABU RAM VS UoI
15	O.A. 1281/CH/2012 ADVOCATE: SHRI ROHIT SETH	Sh. Babu Ram, working as Upper Division Clerk, working in the Central Administrative Tribunal, opposite Shivalik View Hotel, Sector 17, Chandigarh VS UOI	09.05.2013	CAT CHNDIGARH BENCH	allow this OA in terms of the view obtained in terms of the view obtained in the OA. 1038/CH/11and the judgments (Annexures A-11 to A-13). The compliance of the order must ideally come about within two months from the date a copy of this order is presented in the office of the competent authority.
16	CWP No. 24279 of 2013	U.O.I. .Vs. BABU RAM & ORS.	07.11.2013	HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA	see order of even date passed in CWP No.24278 of 2013 (UOI and another versus Smt.Reeta Devi and another
17	Special Leave to Petition (Civil)10435 OF 2014	U.O.I. .Vs. BABU RAM & ORS		Supreme Court of India	Pending
DHIRENDER SINGH & Ors Vs UoI
18	Civil Writ Petition No.24253 of 2013 Date of Decision:	U,O.I. .Vs. DHIRENDER SINGH & ORS.	07.11.2013	High Court Of Punjab & Haryana At Chandigarh	For orders, see order of even date passed in CWP No.24278 of 2013 (Union of India and another versus Smt. Reeta Devi and another).
19	Special Leave to Petition(Civil)…. 10436 OF 2014	U.O.I. .Vs. DHIRENDER SINGH & ORS.		Supreme Court of India	Pending
20	O.A. 12/CH/2013 By Advocate: Mr.Madan Mohan	Smt. Reeta Devi, Senior Library Attendant, CAT Bench.  Chandigarh. Versus Union of India	22.05.2013	Cat Chandigarh Bench	After going through the judgment passed in the case of Raj Pal (supra), we are in full agreement with the  learned counsel for the parties. Accordingly, the present original application is allowed in same term as of Raj Pal (supra).  Consequently, we quash the orders at Annexures A-1 & A-2. The respondents are further directed to grant the benefit of 2nd MACP in the pay band of Rs.9300-34800 with grade pay of Rs.4600/- from 1.3.2009 (which is the pay scale of next post in the hierarchy).  The respondents are directed to comply with the judgment within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
21	CWP No. 24278 of 2013	Union of India VS Smt. Reeta Devi, & and others	07.11.2014	High Court Of Punjab &Haryana	CWP filed by Respondents dismissed
22	Special Leave Petition(Civil) 22181 OF 2014	U.O.I. & ORS. Vs. REETA DEVI		Supreme Court of India	pending
NARAYAN KALITA Vs UoI
23	O.A. No. 040/00052/2014	Narayan Kalita CPWD Guwahati VS UOI Represented by Secretary GOI, Ministry of Urban and Develoment	Date of  order 25.06.2014 Date of Delivery of Order 7.8.2014	CAT Guwahati Bench	OA is allowed. for grant of MACP in the hierarchy of Promotional post.  Respondent is directed to grant scale of pay (PB-3) of Rs. 15600-39100 + Grade pay 6600/-
24	OA( 1727/2014)  was filed by CPWD Engineers‘ Association in regarding MACP as per promotional hierarchy on 19.5.2014			CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi on	next date of its hearing has been fixed by CAT on 24/09/2014
25	case filed by the Junior Clerks of  Railway -OA No. 1509 of 2013			CAT Kolkata	next date of its hearing has been fixed by CAT on 8th Dec. 2014